The 30 Best Pizza in Sheffield

“We called by last night without a reservation. They accommodated us straight away . The layout allows you to see the pizzas being made which is interesting. We ordered two pizzas and two drinks. There was little delay before they turned up and OMG , the pizzas were in our option ‘ the best pizzas ever’ the dough was light, the ingredients were clearly top notch . We took some home and had it today. Was still great re-heated. A hidden gem. Will be our default pizza place from now on. Well done chefs and team.”

“Bibi only buys top quality products and everything is homemade. From flour for dough to mince for burgers, all top tier. Been going there for over 15 years. Not once i was disappointed.”

“if you want to have a nice meal at home you should definitely use this restaurant, it is an indescribable taste, I definitely recommend you to order from here, it is very delicious, thank you for this beautiful and delicious meal! I definitely recommend it. Definitely use it!!!!”

“My first trip to Pinos and enjoyed all the pizzas, good base and made with love compared to some other local pizza places, friendly staff!”

“I’ve been a regular at Rudy’s for the past two years and it’s definitely one of my favourite spots in Sheffield as a student. So when I brought my family here after graduation - It was such a pleasant experience as per usual and it was so endearing to see that the service and quality of food has remained consistent as it has been since my first visit! Our server Kim was really nice, she offered me free prosecco for graduating and also an extra dessert on the house even though we already ordered two! The pizzas came out really quickly and the servers were very attentive IE Asking us how we wanted the pizzas to be served, constantly refilling our water jugs. I’ll miss Rudy’s greatly as I graduate and move away from Sheffield as I had so many pleasant memories here especially for its price range, and I hope everyone else will get to experience it too!”

“Beautiful restaurant with lovely owner and amazing Pizzas!!!!! We had the special stake pizza, goats cheese pizza and had some drinks! The price was great and we also had some lovely gelatos that were great quantity :) The restaurant was full but they called us for when the space was empty and it was great :)!! Highly recommend it :)!”

“The best pizzas in Retford, properly made and full of flavour, not grease. Added the chips to this order - best in Retford too!”

“Absolutely fantastic! Da Leo Italian Restaurant & Pizza is a true gem — the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve stepped right into Italy for an evening. The food is bursting with authentic flavour; you can tell everything’s made with real care and fresh ingredients. The pizzas are perfect — thin, crispy crusts with generous toppings — and the pasta dishes are rich, comforting, and beautifully presented. The staff are friendly and attentive without being overbearing, and the whole atmosphere feels relaxed and welcoming.”

“Top quality. Mint looking menu and a great variety of pizzas.”

“This place is the closest I have ever had to the pizza in Napoli. Really authentic, tasty food!”

“Absolutely amazing food and will definitely be ordering again. My son said the pepperoni pizza is the best he’s ever tasted!! Great service and great staff. Thank you guys”

“I had an amazing experience at this restaurant! The highlight of my meal was the mashed potatoes and eggs. The mashed potatoes were creamy, buttery, and perfectly seasoned. The eggs were fluffy and cooked to perfection, complementing the potatoes beautifully. The combination was simple yet incredibly satisfying. The ambiance was cozy, and the staff were friendly and attentive. I'll definitely be back for more of that delicious comfort food!”

“An amazing place to enjoy a beer, glass of wine and beautiful pizza, fries and nibbles. The pizzas are so tasty and the beer and wine selection is really good quality. Love it that Abbeydale Brewery beers are always on at least one tap, a very local brewery, they are a few hundred metres across the road. As well as amazing food, the service is so good. Tonight, one of the team checked with the table next to us on their order as they are regulars and one of the ingredients sounded different to the normal order. They were right! Great attention to detail and care. We have been coming here for years and realised we have not reviewed it. Should have done ages ago. Also, out of 40 odd visits they would all be 5 stars. Thanks Gary and team for a brilliant neighbourhood restaurant. Last point! If you order for delivery it's still great!”

“Probably the best East-Asian food I've eaten at a restaurant. Excellent service and the food came promptly. The chef and owner explained different points on the menu in a very clear manner and gave great recommendations. The food itself was brilliant, the best part was that everything is halal since they don't use any pork and only use halal meat. The atmosphere of the restaurant was excellent. We were actually the only ones there at the time. I personally was a big fan of all the paintings hung up on the walls. The owner even explained the cultural significance behind some of them and what they meant. Overall a 10/10 experience. Would recommend to anyone thinking of going there and I'd definitely come back if I'm ever in the area again.”

“The best pizza - Luigi hand stretches all the bases personally, unlike most of the pizza shops around here that use pre-made bases. The prices have barely increased in the 30+ years that this place has been open. He doesn't deliver, he doesn't need to, its that popular. If you want a Friday tea-time pizza phone it in or you will be waiting, it's that popular.”

“One of our regulars at home. Something for everyone. Delivery has always been fast and food nice and hot. My favourite is the kebab box's. Excellent value and packed.”

“First time i have ever had from here tonight and the food was so nice best takeaway i have had for a long time”

“Went for the first time to this family run business after a recommendation & reading reviews. This is the best kebab we have ever had. We ordered one chicken & one doner kebab. The amount of meat we got & the quality was outstanding. The sauces were amazing especially the chilli. The best chilli sauce ever. Now onto the staff. So pleasant & friendly. These guys deserve your business. Give it a try you won’t be disappointed. We are definitely returning.”

“The food was hot and tasty, and the calzone was lovely. It was a bit quiet when we arrived, but it was filling up a bit by the time we left. Conrad was our waiter, and was great!”

“Excellent Italian restaurant over two floors, both rooms quite small. Very good service and delicious food; between us we tried several seafood pasta dishes, and a Caprese starter (which oddly had rocket instead of Basil, but was still very tasty). Good value wines and friendly and relaxed service.”

“Jeremias has been an exceptional waiter tonight, we’ve had a lovely time celebrating my partners 32nd birthday! Food is the best of the best as usual, thanks team”

“Brilliant place. Really good value and tastes so good! I had the seafood pasta and it was the best one I’ve had in a while with as much seafood as there were noodles. Great menu as well and bring your own wine deal. Will definitely come back x”

“The food is absolutely amazing. Delivery is quick everytime and the food is hot. This is 100% the best place in sutton to order from without a doubt.”

“We hired Boom Battle Bar in Sheffield for our staff Christmas Party last Friday (28th Nov) and all 50 of us had a great time. The staff were fun and friendly and even though they were a team member down in the kitchen they still served our food as planned which was very nice. Thank you for having us!”

“Brilliant staff. Good food and good atmosphere. Ten out of ten”

“Always ordering from here of we having takeaway best pizza,kebab and burgers in Doncaster hands down”

“Called in here tonight on my journey back home. Straight away I was greeted with a warm friendly welcome. I ordered a thin crust meat feast pizza garlic sauce and can of tango which came to £15.40. The pizza itself was very tasty with plenty of toppings however the star of the show was the garlic mayo. I have never had such a morish sauce in my life. I would highly recommend visiting this place if your in the area.”

“Quality pizza. I had the ortolona which is already vegetarian with eggplants as the main topping. Though I think fungi is a better option since its mushrooms were more spread out across the pizza, and the sauces better complimented mushroom. Sat downstairs around the bar. Didn't feel like any drinks but the same waiters kept coming back to ask about it. Had such a great time i forgot to take photos much.”

“Excellent restaurant. We came on a Friday and had from the Pan Asian Fusion Menu. The food tasted amazing and the service was great. Definitely coming here again!”

“Came here to dine on the way home and boy was I surprised the service is excellent polite courteous and helpful there is a range of drinks available including a nice selection of non alcoholic drinks that are very reasonably priced then the food they have a beautiful menu with a very nice vegan selection the pizzas are fresh with fresh toppings and beautifully cooked and presented all in all the best pizza place iv found in Chesterfield and surrounding areas a definite spot to come and dine also the prices are very good considering the quality of the food Hi all well new place but just as good if not better than I remember awsome service fabulous food just an amazing time the staff are super nice all the ingredients are fresh and taste delicious and the pizza was Cooked to perfection well worth a visit whether your on your own a couple wanting a romantic meal or a party it's a great time with amazing food”