Italian restaurant in Sheffield

“I’ve been a regular at Rudy’s for the past two years and it’s definitely one of my favourite spots in Sheffield as a student. So when I brought my family here after graduation - It was such a pleasant experience as per usual and it was so endearing to see that the service and quality of food has remained consistent as it has been since my first visit! Our server Kim was really nice, she offered me free prosecco for graduating and also an extra dessert on the house even though we already ordered two! The pizzas came out really quickly and the servers were very attentive IE Asking us how we wanted the pizzas to be served, constantly refilling our water jugs. I’ll miss Rudy’s greatly as I graduate and move away from Sheffield as I had so many pleasant memories here especially for its price range, and I hope everyone else will get to experience it too!”

“If you like Italian food,then you don't need to look any further than here. We booked a very early evening time slot on a saturday evening for 5.00pm. Thinking we would get there before the crowds. How wrong can you be? The car park was almost full. This is no more a hidden gem. It's shining in the spotlight and so pleased to see them doing so well. This is one of those very rare restaurants, where if you can't choose what to order you could just leave up to the chef to decide for you. The food is all so fresh and absolutely delicious. Even though they were busy,the service was spot on and friendly. Staff are totally on the ball and constantly checking on every table. If you are going to go,make sure you book!”

“A hidden little gem of a place ... We've driven past this place many a times on our way to town - not thinking much of it.. it's a shame we didn't try it sooner! Food: Fantastically tasty food, which was prompt and well presented. On the first visit, there was a substitute on my tagliatelle - but this is because it's all made fresh that day and we arrived one hour before closing. Tried a few different starters/sharing plates, both were beautiful and (as much as I know) tasted authentic. Each following visit has been equally beautiful food. Service: First time, we arrived an hour before closing (cause... Yolo and we were hungry) and they were still very welcoming and accommodating. We still weren't rushed to order out food, even with the time. Everyone was friendly, polite and helpful. On following visits, everyone has been beyond lovely on each visit ... Atmosphere: Decorated with little touches of Sicily - it has a nice ambience for the type of food and cuisine served. It can get a little loud, with the size of the room, but nothing to stop you visiting this beautiful little gem. Would definitely recommend and will continue to return.”

“Absolutely fantastic! Da Leo Italian Restaurant & Pizza is a true gem — the kind of place that makes you feel like you’ve stepped right into Italy for an evening. The food is bursting with authentic flavour; you can tell everything’s made with real care and fresh ingredients. The pizzas are perfect — thin, crispy crusts with generous toppings — and the pasta dishes are rich, comforting, and beautifully presented. The staff are friendly and attentive without being overbearing, and the whole atmosphere feels relaxed and welcoming.”

“This really is a secret gem in Barnsley. A small but very friendly atmosphere, great host and absolutely delicous food. Would highly recommend you book now as they book up months in advance!”

“The food was simply stunning from start to finish All the staff were super friendly and accommodating Would highly recommend!”

“Had a lovely afternoon tea as a birthday treat. The food was beautiful staff were friendly and helpful. A very nice experience and I would highly recommend this place”

“Italian mixed grill, didn't get the name. Brst piece of pork I've ever tasted, exceptional meal. Great welcoming staff and a cracking atmosphere.”

“Me my wife and my two children booked a table on Sunday I pushed the boat out and went for my favourite steak which was cooked to absolute perfection. The staff are so welcoming and the atmosphere is perfect for a restaurant. As always we will be visting again”

“Went to castleton for a holiday and was so bored of eating pub food so decided to try 1530. The building was constructed in 1530 hence the name. I went there with my partner to have some quality time. The service, food, wine pairing and atmosphere was just so good. They even have some vegetarian options and that was a win for me! 10/10 would visit again if I’m back in castleton!”

“Lovely restaurant with amazing food and service”

“Came in late on a Sunday and got a lovely warm welcome from our waitress. Food was excellent and it was great to meet the owner. Thank you we will definitely be back.”

“Busy Saturday night, so had to book ahead, but we'll worth it. Food was really good, plenty of choice on the menu and specials board, nice atmosphere, would definitely return”

“Just had a fantastic meal at Paulos Don't miss out this is a real hidden gem If you like good food you will not be disappointed”

“Lovely meal at papa’s for the 8th year running. I had the lobster ravioli which was lush, the cannoli which was superb and the lemon pancakes which were divine - you cannot come here and not have the lemon pancakes they are the nicest thing you will ever eat.”

“Wow! To be honest this was an impromptu visit on the last night of our stay in the lovely Tideswell, and it’s a gem! Phoned up and Sal fitted us in on a table that was booked from 7:30pm… no problem. We took our own alcohol as advised by him on the phone. I had a Calzone and my wife one of the chicken specials. I finished my calzone which was so so delicious and so rare for me to do so. Two completely clean plates. The atmosphere was lovely and to be honest the sheer openness and friendliness of the front of house was amazing. It’s a shame we found this gem on our last night.”

“I highly recommend it. If you want a delicious and filling meal, and what's more, be served by Mr. Marek, whose professionalism and personal manners are truly unparalleled, this is the place for you. P.S. Mr. Marek, warm greetings from the couple you hosted on a rainy, cold evening. Thanks to you, the evening was a success.”

“The best Italian restaurant in Rotherham. The food is beautiful and soo hot, the service is welcoming and very friendly, its a family run restaurant and you really get that feeling from the atmosphere. Priced fairly its the second time we've been but certainly won't be the last. Keep doing what your doing!”

“Visited on Saturday, sat outside as weather was good, food and service was fantastic”

“Lovely little restaurant, very attentive and entertaining host, great service and fantastic food! We will definitely be returning”

“Tried for the first time tonight after being told to try off many different friends. Amazing quality food, great prices and freebies!! Service was brilliant, I looked at the wrong menu online but they were patient and made things for me that were not on the menu. We will be back especially now we have seen the amount of choice on the correct menu.”

“This place is absolutely amazing. Every time I ring with a different request they deliver. If u want something different to the standard menu, just give them a bell. Seriously, it’s the best u can get delivered. Even if they are busy, if u need it quick they deliver and it’s always absolutely bang on. Never leave a review but they deserve a good ‘en”

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Domo Italian Restaurant, and it was truly an exceptional experience from start to finish. The food was bursting with authentic Italian flavors and beautifully presented. I enjoyed a dish with rich tomato sauce and tender octopus served with toasted bread — it was packed with bold, comforting flavors and cooked to perfection. I also had the steak and prawns in a flavorful, velvety sauce a real showstopper. On top of that, we shared a generous portion of mixed fried seafood crispy, golden, and perfectly seasoned, accompanied by a variety of dipping sauces and lemon wedges. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with that charming rustic Italian touch. Staff were attentive, friendly, and made us feel truly welcome. The only minor downside was that the food took a little while to arrive, but considering how busy the place was, it’s totally understandable and honestly, the quality of the dishes made it worth the wait. If you’re after a true taste of Italy with vibrant dishes and great service, Domo is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be back!”

“The food was hot and tasty, and the calzone was lovely. It was a bit quiet when we arrived, but it was filling up a bit by the time we left. Conrad was our waiter, and was great!”

“Absolutely top notch food and service, nothing was too much trouble for the team there, Zack gets a special mention for his bright and pleasant approach. Having visited Italy many times and eaten (far too much!) there, I can confidently say this is the closest to a real Italian experience you will get in the UK. Will be back!”

“A lovely experience! Great and friendly service Very quick and attentive Good choice of food - our mussels, calzone and lasagne were all beautifully presented, tasty and good portion sizes Would recommend to anyone:)”

“Brilliant place. Really good value and tastes so good! I had the seafood pasta and it was the best one I’ve had in a while with as much seafood as there were noodles. Great menu as well and bring your own wine deal. Will definitely come back x”

“First time trying this restaurant, the food was great and full of flavor, Feels like home inside, nice and cozy! The staff are very welcoming and helpful. I Would recommend a bigger selection of none alcoholic drinks such as mocktails and 0% wines and beers for people who are pregnant or sober, as you only served becks blue and pop. Will definitely be returning! Thanks :)”

“First time in Sheffield and of course first time here. Incredible food and perfect sized portions. It's very busy so would book in advance, the service is ok, could be slightly more efficient but it's a busy place. For myself being half deaf, I did find this a noisy environment, also due to it being super busy. So just a couple of things to bare in mind. But would highly recommend! Will return in the future”

“Excellent Italian restaurant over two floors, both rooms quite small. Very good service and delicious food; between us we tried several seafood pasta dishes, and a Caprese starter (which oddly had rocket instead of Basil, but was still very tasty). Good value wines and friendly and relaxed service.”