Advertisements

Browse insurance agencies in Sheffield. Use this directory to compare ratings, reviews, photos, opening hours, addresses and contact details. 257 results in Sheffield. Average rating 4.5/5 based on 55,506 reviews & ratings. The listings below include insurance agencies from cities such as Sheffield, Rotherham, Chesterfield, Doncaster, Barnsley and others.

Directory overview

  • 257 Total businesses
  • 4.5 Average rating
  • 82% With reviews
  • 56% With photos
  • 39 Highly rated
  • 110 Open on weekends
Advertisements

Rating distribution

How many businesses fall in each rating band (rated only).

Advertisements

Top-rated at a glance

Businesses ranked by rating confidence — rating combined with review volume.

Business Rating Reviews Category Best for
Protection 1st 5.0 8 Insurance Agency Critical illness cover

Browse by city

Nearby regions

Advertisements
  1. 1
    Photo of Bairstow Eves Sales and Letting Agents Kirkby-in-Ashfield - 32 Station St, Kirkby in Ashfield, Nottingham NG17 7AS, UK

    Bairstow Eves Sales and Letting Agents Kirkby-in-Ashfield

    ★★★★★ 5 (200 Reviews) Top rated Closed

    “The team have been wonderful supporting us to put our home on the market. Lesley was friendly, honest and personable when visiting us and ensured she gave realistic expectations. When contacting the office the rest of the team knew exactly who we were and the details of our home, it really showed how great of a team they are, Jo and Emily were also so professional and friendly! We would definitely recommend the team to all our friends and family and will use them again in the future if we wish to move again.”

    Address: 32 Station St, Kirkby in Ashfield, Nottingham NG17 7AS, UK
    Phone: +44 1623 240291
    Website: bairstoweves.co.uk
  2. 2
    Photo of First Mortgage Sheffield - 32 Eyre St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4QZ, UK

    First Mortgage Sheffield

    ★★★★★ 5 (57 Reviews) Top rated Closed

    “I would highly recommend First Mortgage. Rose and Yusuf were absolutely brilliant throughout the entire process. They were knowledgeable and incredibly supportive every step of the way. Their guidance made what could have been a stressful time feel smooth and manageable. I couldn’t have asked for a better team—highly recommended!”

    Address: 32 Eyre St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4QZ, UK
    Phone: +44 114 437 2616
    Website: firstmortgage.co.uk
  3. 3
    Photo of Gee Vee Travel Sheffield - 23 Holme Ln, Hillsborough, Sheffield S6 4JP, UK

    Gee Vee Travel Sheffield

    ★★★★☆ 4.6 (58 Reviews) Top rated Closed

    “Just got back from a holiday in Torquay at the Nethway Hotel great people made you feel at home throughout our stay. Barry our driver was the best couldnt do enough for us i will definitely go back again. thankyou Christine Johnson”

    Address: 23 Holme Ln, Hillsborough, Sheffield S6 4JP, UK
    Phone: +44 114 232 3366
    Website: geeveetravel.co.uk
Advertisements
  1. 4
    Photo of Spire Insurance - North Midland House/Corporation St, Chesterfield S41 7UB, UK

    Spire Insurance

    ★★★★☆ 4.6 (60 Reviews) Top rated Closed

    “Very good fast and friendly and professional. Top man helped me out. First time taxi driver yes expensive but customer service was fantastic. Felt like if there was a problem these guys could sort it. Thanks again for sorting out my insurance.”

    Address: North Midland House/Corporation St, Chesterfield S41 7UB, UK
    Phone: +44 1246 551457
  2. 5
    Photo of One Call Insurance - First Point, Balby Carr Bank, Doncaster DN4 5JQ, UK

    One Call Insurance

    ★★★★☆ 4.5 (41,385 Reviews) Top rated Closed

    “Used the online chat option on the morning of 1/9/25 to discuss my renewal quote and cheaper quotes received elsewhere. The agent delivered a quick and thorough review and was able to match my lowest quote received. I was dealt with in a very courteous and professional manner. Well done One Call!”

    Address: First Point, Balby Carr Bank, Doncaster DN4 5JQ, UK
    Website: onecallinsurance.co.uk
Advertisements
  1. 8
    Photo of Pub Insurance 4u - Mill One Pleasley Vale Business Park, Pleasley Vale, Mansfield NG19 8RL, UK

    Pub Insurance 4u

    ★★★★★ 4.8 (28 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “I've been using this company for a number of years to insure my pubs and have dealt with Anthony throughout. Anthony has always been extremely helpful in finding me the best quotes with the right cover. Would highly recommend.”

    Address: Mill One Pleasley Vale Business Park, Pleasley Vale, Mansfield NG19 8RL, UK
    Phone: +44 800 644 4262
    Website: pubinsurance4u.co.uk
Advertisements
  1. 10

    D C J Group Insurance

    ★★★★★ 4.8 (16 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “Too often excellent customer service is hard to find. Look no further than this company. Professional,thorough and working for you the customer. I insure two cars with them and they have taken the time to get me quotes which suit me from a cover and cost point of view. To Louise and the team thank you for all your hard work.it is much appreciated. Charles lovatt”

    Address: Lutine House, Brimington Rd N, Whittington Moor, Chesterfield S41 9AP, UK
    Phone: +44 1246 456789
    Website: dcj-insurance.co.uk
  2. 12
    Photo of Sheffield Mutual Friendly Society - 3 Maple Park, Maple Court, Tankersley, Barnsley S75 3DP, UK

    Sheffield Mutual Friendly Society

    ★★★★☆ 4.5 (22 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “Came across Sheffield Mutual about 10 years ago. Have never regretted investing with them. Staff very friendly and welcoming. Have even got to know various members of their team over the years. You wouldn't get that with large financial institutions. I should add that their products are very competitive too. I highly recommend.”

    Address: 3 Maple Park, Maple Court, Tankersley, Barnsley S75 3DP, UK
    Phone: +44 1226 741000
    Website: sheffieldmutual.com
Advertisements
  1. 13
    Photo of Goldthorpe Insurance Brokers - Silicon House, Farfield Park, Manvers Way, Wath upon Dearne, Rotherham S63 5DB, UK

    Goldthorpe Insurance Brokers

    ★★★★☆ 4.4 (26 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “What a fantastic broker, we have used a couple now but Mark for RIB is professional, always on time, listens and explains everything in an understandable language which is always great”

    Address: Silicon House, Farfield Park, Manvers Way, Wath upon Dearne, Rotherham S63 5DB, UK
    Phone: +44 1709 893685
    Website: rib-group.co.uk
  2. 14
    Photo of Rotherham Insurance Brokers - Silicon House, Farfield Park, Manvers Way, Wath upon Dearne, Rotherham S63 5DB, UK

    Rotherham Insurance Brokers

    ★★★★☆ 4.4 (26 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “What a fantastic broker, we have used a couple now but Mark for RIB is professional, always on time, listens and explains everything in an understandable language which is always great”

    Address: Silicon House, Farfield Park, Manvers Way, Wath upon Dearne, Rotherham S63 5DB, UK
    Phone: +44 1709 875548
    Website: rib-group.co.uk
  3. 15

    Yoga Insurance

    ★★★★☆ 4.3 (1,789 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “I recently changed insurance providers. I made a mistake when filling in the documentation giving the wrong information. When I discovered this I panicked. I was going round in circles with an A.I chat, gave up and wrote to the company. I received an extremely prompt reply, and this morning I had a live chat with a lovely person called Abbie. Problem sorted, another worry off my list. Thank you Abbie T”

    Address: Balby Carr Bank, Doncaster DN4 5JQ, UK
    Website: yoga-insure.co.uk
Advertisements
  1. 17
    Photo of Hoyland Insurance Brokers Ltd - 140 West St, Hoyland, Barnsley S74 9DU, UK

    Hoyland Insurance Brokers Ltd

    ★★★★☆ 4.1 (22 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “My business has used Hoyland for over two years now. They remind me each year of the upcoming renewal date to give me time to run through what has changed in the business to make sure I am covered for the following 12 months. In addition, they actively seek out cheaper alternatives instead of just rolling over year on year. Would highly recommend it to anyone with a business who needs the cover and an expert to guide them through.”

    Address: 140 West St, Hoyland, Barnsley S74 9DU, UK
    Phone: +44 1226 744716
    Website: hoylandinsurance.co.uk
  2. 18
    Photo of Virgin Atlantic Holidays Sheffield Meadowhall - Meadowhall Way, Meadowhall, Sheffield S9 1EP, UK

    Virgin Atlantic Holidays Sheffield Meadowhall

    ★★★★☆ 4.1 (105 Reviews) Well rated Closed

    “Came in to the store to have a better understanding after going to other travel agents. Met with Natasha, who was so lovely can I add, and she went through various places, as well as gave recommendations of stuff to do and areas that go with what we wanted to do. Had an amazing experience and ended up booking a very amazing trip for our honeymoon! The deal was incredible. And Natasha made it so easy and comfortable to get exactly what we want!! Would highly recommend the store after not having as good of an experience for our honeymoon holiday elsewhere. And a big part of that was Natasha!”

    Address: Meadowhall Way, Meadowhall, Sheffield S9 1EP, UK
    Phone: +44 344 472 9494
Advertisements
Advertisements
  1. 22

    Walker Midgley Insurance Brokers (Part of the Towergate group of companies)

    ★★★★☆ 4.7 (10 Reviews) Closed

    “Always a good experience renewing vintage tractor policy with WM. No faff, no sales talk and always a good bit of banter to be had. Added another vehicle today and Patricia was everything that I expect when I phone up!! Superb service, outstanding staff and always a really realistic quote. Highly recommended. Rob”

    Address: Floor 5, Derwent House, 150 Arundel Gate, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2FN, UK
    Phone: +44 114 250 2770
Advertisements
Advertisements
  1. 28

    Bupa Health Centre Sheffield

    ★★★★★ 5 (2 Reviews) Closed

    “Edward the Health Assessor was very polite and motivated me to improve my Health.Also Dr Lee was very professional and caring.This is my 2nd Health Assessment via Bupa.It took 2h-1,5h but it is totslly worth it and I received my results via email asap.Many thanks for looking after us.A.G”

    Address: The White House, 3 Sandygate Park, Sheffield S10 5TZ, UK
    Phone: +44 114 263 2058
    Website: bupa.co.uk
  2. 30
    Photo of Actus Insurance - Office 3b, Fox Valley Way, Stocksbridge, Sheffield S36 2AE, UK

    Actus Insurance

    ★★★★★ 5 (2 Reviews) Closed

    “Used Actus for various insurance products. They offer a fantastic service, present the quotes in an easy to understand manner and the staff are great. Would recommend to anyone”

    Address: Office 3b, Fox Valley Way, Stocksbridge, Sheffield S36 2AE, UK
    Phone: +44 114 398 4498
    Website: actusinsurance.co.uk
Advertisements
Advertisements

Frequently asked questions

Answers generated from the current directory data.

How many insurance agencies are there in Sheffield?

We list 257 insurance agencies in Sheffield.

What is the average rating of insurance agencies in Sheffield?

The average rating is 4.5, based on 55,506 reviews.

Which insurance agencies in Sheffield are rated highest?

There are 39 top-rated insurance agencies in Sheffield, for example 5 top-rated: Right Choice Mortgages (5.0★, 426 reviews); Yorkshire Financial Services Ltd (5.0★, 415 reviews); TUI Holiday Store (5.0★, 257 reviews); Mallard Mortgages (5.0★, 247 reviews); William H Brown Estate Agents Retford (5.0★, 231 reviews).

How many are open on weekends?

110 work on weekends.
Advertisements