The 10 Best Italian restaurant in Maidenhead

13 results found

Advertisements
  1. 1

    Presto Italian Street Food

    ★★★★★ 4.9
    Open

    “Hey Presto! From the moment we arrived, the service at this place was exceptional. Despite being a large party of 15, they accommodated us at very short notice—something many places wouldn’t even attempt on a busy weekend day. The manager/owner personally welcomed us, which set the tone for the rest of our visit. He went out of his way to explain that the chicken and lamb are halal, which was not only thoughtful but allowed several of us to explore more of the menu confidently. On his recommendation, we ordered the chicken focaccia, which turned out to be a standout—tender, flavourful, and perfectly balanced. Highly recommended. The pizzas were genuinely authentic Neapolitan style—light, airy crust with just the right char, and high-quality ingredients you can taste in every bite. The food came out quickly, and despite the group size, the waitresses were welcoming, attentive, and incredibly efficient, ensuring everyone was looked after without missing a beat. To finish, we had coffee—and I can honestly say, it was the best I’ve had in Maidenhead. Rich, smooth, and perfectly pulled. We followed that with fresh cannoli, which were the ideal sweet finish. There’s a certain charm to the atmosphere here. With the smell of fresh dough, barista-quality coffee, and the staff’s warmth, if the people around were dressed just a bit more elegantly, you might just mistake yourself for an eaterie in Naples or Rome. This was my first visit to Presto, but absolutely won’t be the last. It’s rare to find a place that delivers great food, personal service, and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere all in one.”

    Address: 6 Bridge Street, Maidenhead SL6 8BJ, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 638889

    Website: prestoitalian.co.uk

  2. 3

    il Cortile Italian Deli

    ★★★★★ 4.8
    Open

    “The BEST hidden gem! The owners are absolutely wonderful – so passionate, welcoming, and friendly, they make you feel like part of the family as soon as you walk in. The food is just delicious, made with genuine Italian ingredients that taste completely different to anything you’ll find in other cafés. Every bite is full of authentic flavour and love. I always recommend this place to friends and tell all my baby massage clients to pop in after class. It is such a lovely spot to enjoy real Italian food and a relaxed atmosphere. A must visit!”

    Address: Maidenhead Road, Warfield, Bracknell RG42 6EJ, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1344 453749

    Website: ilcortiledeli.com

  1. 4

    Storia Maidenhead

    ★★★★☆ 4.7
    Open

    “Easily the best food I've ordered for delivery! This Italian is gorgeous and goes the extra mile with packaging the food up, chilli oil for the pizza and popcorn to snack on! The truffle pizza was full of flavour but the arancini was easily the best. Really recommend this place:) definitely going to reorder”

    Address: 11 Bridge Street, Maidenhead SL6 8LR, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 769350

    Website: storiarestaurants.co.uk

  2. 5

    Alghero Traditional Italian Restaurant

    ★★★★☆ 4.7
    Closed

    “I took my wife for her birthday here, and I must say, it was a memorable experience. The food they served was exceptional, with a diverse menu that catered to a wide range of preferences. From the moment we walked in, the service was top-notch. The staff was attentive and courteous, making us feel truly special. I couldn't have asked for a better dining experience. It's safe to say that this place left a lasting impression on me, and I'm sure to return in the future.”

    Address: 14 Bridge Street, Maidenhead SL6 8BJ, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 636137

    Website: algherorestaurant.co.uk

  3. 6

    SORANO Italian Restaurant Maidenhead

    ★★★★☆ 4.5
    Closed

    “My husband and me went to celebrate his birthday. Food was lovely and good portions. I really like the character of the place. All waitresses were friendly. I have asked them to write on my husband dessert "Happy birthday " and they did it with an extra unexpected birthday singing. They were lovely! We absolutely satisfied with everything. Thank you very much!”

    Address: 1 Bridge Street, Maidenhead SL6 8LR, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 670769

    Website: soranoitalian.co.uk

  1. 7

    Prime Pizza Maidenhead

    ★★★★☆ 4.2
    Open

    “Quick and easy ordering, prep and delivery times perfect, food quite honestly the best Pizza I’ve ever had, very filling and still have half over I’m looking forward to eat next day. Quality food for a quality price. Definitely recommend and I will definitely purchase from Prime Pizza again ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

    Address: 99 Queen Street, Maidenhead SL6 1LR, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 770418

    Website: primepizzamaidenhead.uk

  2. 8

    La Collina

    ★★★★☆ 4.6
    Closed

    “Best food 'takeout' I have personally tried. True authentic Italian food - decided to try the menu items (only had the 10/10 Pizza previously) and it didn't disappoint. Absolutely great meal and good value. These guys need a full restaurant with seating! Glass of vino and a three course meal with them would be great.”

    Address: Cannon Lane, Maidenhead SL6 3NR, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 299823

    Website: lacollinatakeaway.co.uk

  3. 9

    Palmieri's

    ★★★★☆ 4.6
    Open

    “Came across these guys by chance and loved everything about this place SO much, that I cancelled our reservation we had elsewhere the following evening, and we brought our friends here instead!! The service and the food is incredible! If we’re back in Henley again anytime soon we 100% will come back here and will be HIGHLY recommending to anyone visiting, to experience this wonderful eatery!! Absolutely fantastic guys, thank you for giving my tastebuds the best authentic Italian meal they’ve ever had!! STUNNING!”

    Address: 52 Furze Platt Road, Maidenhead SL6 7NN, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 788234

    Website: palmieris.co.uk

  1. 10

    Pizza Della Mamma

    ★★★★☆ 4.5
    Closed

    “Recommended by a friend so thought I'd give it a try as a little pit stop to my journey. Lovely staff and was a delight to see the kitchen in the back making the food and having true care to what they're doing. Pizza was true to the name with an amazingly crisp base and a dough that was so flavoursome! I just went for a simple Margherita as that should shine how good an establishments pizza is; it didn't disappoint. Tangy dough from its fermentation, beautifully sweet but salted tomato base with creamy cheese. It didn't make the journey home and I was eating slices at the wheel!”

    Address: 57 Queen Street, Maidenhead SL6 1LT, United Kingdom

    Phone: +44 1628 290910

    Website: pizzadellamamma.co.uk